I totally understand your dilemma. I try to keep my “non main” dolls and toys in boxes, but I did sell some of them to get money and space. I usually don’t regret it, especially if I have enough memories and pictures with them. But I try to choose the ones I don’t use anymore. If I feel I’m not enjoying taking photos or doing restyles with a doll/toy, I just put it on sale. Thinking about what you want to do with the money might help.

I don’t regret any sales I made, except my Enchantix Musa from Mattel, years ago, and sometimes my old Monster High dolls. But it was never like : “I’m so stupid ! Why did I do that !?”

I get it. I need to do the same. I usually start with duplicate dolls/toys in my collection. Selling those doesn’t hurt as much since I still have the item in my collection. If you don’t have any duplicates, then I would just pick a line that just isn’t doing it for you anymore and go through each one. If you feel “meh” about it, put it away somewhere for a while, then look at it again. If you feel the same, it’s time to rehome it.

As for the actual selling, I’ve sold on eBay and Mercari. They both have their pros and cons, and because these platforms charge fees, that does cut into the amount you will receive. Semi-pro tips: if you plan to ship, it’s best to have the packaging ready and weighed, so you know how much shipping to charge. That may change if someone purchases multiple items from you, but at least you will have a baseline for each listing. I have been burned by not charging enough shipping, and then you are at the mercy of the shipper as to what the extra fees are. It can be exorbitant. I lost money on a doll once because I didn’t charge adequate shipping. Hope this helps!

No advice, just solidarity. I’m also feeling like I need to downsize a little, but I’m not sure where to start!

Thank you so much for your input! It has helped me get rid of 12 dolls so far.

Such a fun list! Thanks for sharing. I don’t have any of these dolls except coffee break frankie, but I love to see them in others’ collections

I loved seeing them together, great pics! The both have such pretty faces and hair. Wynter looks like she’s made of ice.